Tuesday, December 4, 2007



Today's Local Real Estate News: "This is the most serious housing downturn since the Great Depression."

The local newspapers provided extensive coverage of mortgage crisis and the proposed intervention in the Treasury Secretary Paulson. The Sun-Sentinel reports:

“The chief executive officer of the country's biggest mortgage lender says greater government intervention is needed to rescue the U.S. housing market as his peers warn the worst is yet to come.”

“Daniel Mudd, chief executive of government-backed mortgage finance company Fannie Mae, called intervention a "positive step," saying that many borrowers will be able to avoid foreclosure if they are given more time. "Largely, the industry is beginning to reconstruct itself," Mudd said.”

“The gloomy assessments of the housing market were made Monday at a conference sponsored by the Office of Thrift Supervision, where Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson said an agreement is imminent to temporarily freeze interest rates on thousands of mortgages at risk of default.”

“Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody's Economy.com, predicted that, if the economy slips into recession or if efforts to modify home loans don't pick up substantially, the housing market downturn could last through the end of the decade.”

“‘This is the most serious housing downturn since the Great Depression,’ Zandi said.”

“In South Florida and across the nation, mortgage defaults are rising, and experts warn that more people will lose their homes to lenders in 2008.’

The Miami Herald reports:

“Revealing more details about a national mortgage-rescue plan that's still in the works, Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson proposed Monday to help state and local governments issue tax-exempt bonds to pay for mortgage refinancing and confirmed that he seeks to temporarily freeze the rates of tens of thousands of home loans that are about to adjust to higher rates.”

“Paulson told a national housing forum that Congress should authorize state and local governments to broaden their tax-exempt bond programs temporarily. Currently, states have authorization to issue tax-exempt bonds only to aid first-time home buyers in designated distress zones. Paulson proposed to expand this to allow state and local governments to issue tax-free bonds to help in mortgage refinancing.”

“He also confirmed that he is trying to craft a plan that would prevent massive foreclosures when roughly 1.5 million adjustable-rate mortgages, or ARMs, reset to higher monthly rates next year. The affected ARMs involve subprime loans -- those given to borrowers with weak credit histories.”

“‘'As volume increases, we will need an aggressive systematic approach to fast-track able borrowers into a refinance or mortgage modification,'' Paulson said. He stressed that there would be no government subsidy to borrowers or lenders.”

Finally, the Palm Beach Post adds:

“Until now, President Bush favored government restraint. But with investors losing millions as Wall Street banks write down billions of dollars in bad home-loan investments amid mounting concerns about economic stability, the White House is pressuring the mortgage industry to offer a sweeping fix for the problem.”

“The Bush administration is "willing to consider action that would have been inconceivable just weeks ago," mortgage industry consultant Howard Glaser wrote in a research note.”

“That doesn't mean the rate-freeze approach being promoted by Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson won't face resistance from mortgage industry executives. And some on Wall Street warn of a flood of lawsuits if the government tries to coerce the owners of loans held in complex mortgage securities to focus on long-term rather than short-term returns.”

“‘I don't think (the Treasury plan is) being very well-received at all," said Bert Ely, a banking consultant based in Alexandria, Va. ‘There are lots of legal issues here that they are not addressing that are in the minds of everybody who works on this stuff.’”

“Details of the Treasury plan, which could be formally unveiled later this week, stops short of a taxpayer-funded bailout for borrowers, an idea rejected by both Democrats and Republicans. Some specifics of the plan have trickled out, such as homeowners being given a break of two to five years if they are currently making payments on time but wouldn't be able to do so when their mortgages adjust to higher rates.”

While the following story has absolutely nothing to do with the local market, I believe that the exact same situation exists here locally. It also shows why I believe Paulson efforts will have little effect. The Nevada Appeal reports on foreclosures in Las Vegas:

“The head of an independent Southern Nevada research firm told lawmakers Monday nearly 60 percent of homes in foreclosure there are not occupied by their owners.”

“That means they are either rentals or homes purchased by speculators during the housing boom of the past couple of years.”

“Jeremy Aguero, of Applied Analysis in Las Vegas, said of the nearly 30,000 unsold homes on the market, 42 percent are vacant and another 11 percent occupied by renters.”

“Duncan said Nevada, California, Arizona and Florida are in the same situation and the cause is a mix of over-development and speculative investment.”

“‘Housing construction should be in proportion to population growth but there's been a dramatic increase in housing construction compared to population growth," he said. ‘That probably indicates over-building. There's a massive supply of houses on the market.’”

“But the market has effectively collapsed, not just in Nevada but nationwide. Homes are now on the market for months, selling sporadically when owners agree to drop prices. And with adjustable-rate mortgages beginning to trigger, many homeowners and investors are finding they can't afford their new, higher payments.”

“He said large numbers of those speculators who see their investment dropping in value and the market stalled ‘will simply turn in the keys and walk away.’ When they do that, he said, the house doesn't show as delinquent.”

“Aguero said there are more than 6,000 foreclosures in Nevada ‘in the pipe’ today. And Duncan said the situation won't turn around soon.”

“‘We expect sales will continue to fall for some time," he said.”

The International Herald Tribune reports on the run on the state-run investment account:

“Florida schools and towns with money frozen in a state-run investment account are unlikely to get their cash back Tuesday when officials are scheduled to meet to discuss a crisis prompted by withdrawals that drained almost half of the fund's $27 billion in assets, a policy officer said.”

“‘If we reopen the window without limitations on Tuesday, and we see behavior like we've seen up to now, there's simply no way to meet that demand without having a fire sale on assets,’ said the policy officer, James Francis, who works at the State Board of Administration, the manager of the Local Government Investment Pool.”

“In a conference call Friday, a day after withdrawals were frozen, officials raised the possibility of paying less than 100 cents on the dollar to governments seeking cash. The board also hired BlackRock, the largest U.S. publicly traded money manager, as an adviser.”

“Florida counties and schools pulled out $13 billion in assets last month after learning that the pool, described by state officials as a money market fund, held $1.5 billion of downgraded and defaulted debt tainted by the subprime mortgage market collapse. The crisis shows the far-ranging effects of the housing slump, as complex investments once sold as high-yielding havens are now backed by collateral that investors do not want.”


The Sun-Sentinel reports on asset liquidations by local-builder Lennar Corp.:

“Home builder Lennar Corp. formed a land investment venture with Morgan Stanley Real Estate to acquire, develop, manage and sell residential real estate, with Miami-based Lennar selling properties valued at $1.3 billion to the venture for $525 million.”

“The acquired properties include about 11,000 home sites in 32 communities throughout the country, consisting of raw land as well as partially and fully developed home sites in Florida, California, Colorado, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Nevada and New Jersey.”

“As of Sept. 30, the acquired properties had a book value of about $1.3 billion for one of the nation's largest home builders.”

“The deal generates immediate cash for Miami-based Lennar and is a continuation of the company's strategy of seeking to become a "near assetless home builder," Wachovia Capital Markets analyst Carl Reichardt wrote in a Monday report.”

“JP Morgan research analyst Michael Rehaut wrote that the $775 million loss on the deal as a "net negative" for Lennar and the home-building industry because it points to more impairment charges on assets.”

“‘We believe the loss on the sale is a major negative, as it shows charges are far from over,’ Rehaut wrote.”

The Sun-Sentinel reports on the proposed “Save our Homes” portability amendment:

“This so-called portability is one part of a new tax plan that also would increase the existing $25,000 homestead exemption to about $40,000 and cap taxes for businesses and second-home owners. The package needs the approval of at least 60 percent of voters on Jan. 29 to take effect.”

“While portability would reward longtime residents, it would do nothing for first-time home buyers or retirees from out of state and may not immediately help people who bought at the peak of the housing boom in 2005.”

“‘It's far from perfect,’ said Lori Parrish, Broward County's property appraiser. ‘But it's something. It's another tool in the toolbox for home buyers and sellers.’”

“Many South Florida homeowners are staying put to avoid those huge tax increases, and that has contributed to the housing market's malaise. Home sales across the region have declined for at least two years, in part because of the property tax implications people face when they move.”

The Sun-Sentinel reports on efforts to build affordable housing in Delray Beach:

“Improvements on a run-down apartment building in Delray Beach are progressing, and the contractor plans to finish the affordable-housing project by the end of the year.”

“Once completed, the Delray Beach Community Land Trust will administer the property. Rentals will range from $301 to $724 a month, depending on income.”

“The building is part of the city's $40 million effort to improve the West Settlers Historic District, a historically black neighborhood attracting some white residents. The building is down the street from the rear of the former LaFrance Hotel, which was reopened in November after it was made into affordable housing for low-income seniors.”

29 comments:

Anonymous said...

How Florida Might Unfreeze a Fund

By Craig Karmin and Tom Lauricella
Word Count: 1,009 | Companies Featured in This Article: BlackRock Financial Management, Merrill Lynch

Officials in Florida are scrambling to reopen a state-run fund that has been crippled by withdrawals from local governments and school districts amid worries about its exposure to subprime-mortgage loans.

The fund's investment managers have hired BlackRock Financial Management, which yesterday outlined a plan to revive the state's Local Government Investment Pool. The pool was recently valued at $27 billion and is now valued at $14 billion. This fund manages cash accounts for state school districts and local governments, which had been pulling their money out en masse until withdrawals were frozen.

Solutions won't come easily. BlackRock officials said the ...

Anonymous said...

“But the market has effectively collapsed, not just in Nevada but nationwide. Homes are now on the market for months, selling sporadically when owners agree to drop prices.

That sentence says it all.
I sold last month, closed three weeks after signing contract!
HOW?
I DROPPED THE PRICE!!!
It's NOT rocket science.

Anonymous said...

I don't get it. Florida is still fighting over bonkers property taxes when the agenda should have shifted to introducing a state income tax. Only putting off the inevitable, and I can assure you, the out-of-staters,are not coming back under current proposals. What next, eh? Various Florida funds have exposure to CDOs...ah yes, let's tax the non-residents for our errors.

When Florida and Floridians pay with their own to live in their own, you'll start heading back to equilibrium.

And why doesn't Paulson say it how it is - devalue the dollar, get inflation up and bingo, nominal debt loads.

Anonymous said...

When the guv’ment realized that the voters wouldn’t tolerate a taxpayer-funded bailout of the CDO-laden hedge funds, they guv’ment tried to get all the big banks to fund the Super-SIV. When the big banks balked and drug their feet at funding the Super-SIV, the guv’ment turned to this latest ploy. Again, it won’t work because it’s a voluntary program. Have you ever seen a bank volunteer to reduce their rates?

Without the force of legislation, nothing will work. Fortunately, American voters aren’t exactly warm to Socialist-type tactics of forcing private industry to prop up irresponsible consumers. Therefore, it would be political suicide to implement any type of legislation that forced the lenders to be kind to the down-trodden subprime borrowers, especially in an election year.

In the end, the Dems will blame the Pubs; the Pubs will blame the Dems. It will become a huge, if not the principle, election-year issue. At least the Bushies will say they tried to get something done. The Dems will just go on blaming everything one the Bushies.

Remember just a few years ago both the Dems and the Pubs were touting record homeownership as a marvelous achievement?

Dumbasses – all of them.

Let the free market work. Let the hedge fund investors take it in the shorts. Let a lenders go bankrupt. Let those who bought too much home go into foreclosure. It will hurt for a while, but ultimately it will be a good thing.

Anonymous said...

Rents here in SE Florida appear to be tanking. Finally!!!!

South Florida Housing Bubble said...

Someone send me the following that supports give even more support to my theory that efforts to freeze interest rates will have little impact on the foreclosure crisis.

Here's the link to the article: Fed Report on Foreclosure Cause

Here's some quotes from the article:

"The recent spike in home foreclosures in Massachusetts is caused primarily by falling housing prices, and not by rising mortgage payments, according to research released yesterday by the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston."

"The contrarian report suggests the common understanding of the foreclosure crisis is somewhat mistaken. Unaffordable loans don't cause foreclosures directly. Even as subprime lending became more common, even when people fell behind on mortgage payments - during the economic downturn in 2001, for example - foreclosures were rare because house prices continued to rise."

"In part, people were able to escape trouble by selling their homes at prices high enough to cover their debts. But the research also suggests that troubled borrowers tried harder to make the necessary payments, in the expectation they would profit eventually."

"Conversely, when prices started falling, people struggling to make payments had less incentive to find the money. And the value of the home could drop below the outstanding debt, making it impossible to sell. Over the last two years, the number of foreclosures exploded."

Anonymous said...

SFHB,

In addition to that, I have been seeing that the real deals in waterfronts have not been the bank repos, but the estates and other highly motivated sellers.
My point being that it appears that the laws of supply and demand are causing substantial price drops in the waterfront housing market without the REO influence.
The banks are acting like greedy homeowners, and will need to take a thrashing along with the rest of the speculators.

Peter said...

I sold in September of 2006 our east Hollywood home and moved to NC. We still have a business in the Hallandale Beach-Aventura area that serves the high end HELOC crowd. Our sales are down 50% over last year. People who used credit cards to buy consumables are broke. I always thought that we would be insulated because we served DINKs.

I can't be really specific about what we do, but the newer condo buyers in 33009, 33019 and 33180 are broke. That's why they are going into foreclosure. They spent more than they earned and paid mortgages with borrowed money and the faucet has been shut off.

I was in 3801 S Ocean in 33019 about 2 years ago delivering. There was an open house with a low floor 1/1 conversion listed at $449K. I did a quick cash flow and came up with a monthly payment of 4K PITIM. I saw the light that day.

Anonymous said...

Hello Everyone!
I just wanted to remind you, that Florida is still the best place to live on the east coast. Look at the weather up north or NW or the Midwest. Just keep bashing Florida, while enjoying the sun and the warm weather.

Anonymous said...

"Drivers in much of the Northeast navigated a treacherous mix of rain, sleet and snow Monday as a storm blamed for at least 16 deaths slid through the region after pounding the Upper Midwest."

I know it sucks to live in Florida!

Anonymous said...

It was me, Braziliano with the last 2 comments.

Anonymous said...

I hope this works!

Anonymous said...

Wilma convinced me to move.

It was only a cat. 1 or a low cat 2. storm. Imagine what will happen to South Florida housing market if a cat. 3 hits Broward County.

I now live in the mountains and loving it.

Anonymous said...

Braziliano said...

I hope this works!

Braz,

Nobody I know of on this blog badmouths Fla.
We are just adamant that anyone who buys a home in S Fla this year will lose their arse.
That is a fact, NOT a bashing. If you pick up a poisonous snake, it will bite you. I'm not badmouthing the snake, it's the nature of the beast.
Don't mix us up with the Fla hating morons on the SS Topix threads.
Personally I love Fla, but I'll be G-damned if I'm gonna buy a house today knowing prices will be much much lower in the coming years.

Anonymous said...

140!

Prices may drop a bit more, but if you are waiting for "much lower" prices, you might never get them. None of us know where the market will level off, not you, not me, nobody. And yes, there is lots of "Florida bashing "going on here and many other blogs!

Anonymous said...

Fl deserves to be bashed!! Corruption on all levels. 40% of the economy based on real estate, come on!! Jobs pay low wages yet, housing went thru the roof, much more than other areas. Great place to live if your retired yet, they screw snowbirds and tax-out recent retirees. Homes built on postage stamp lots, where builders make a fortune on margin. Millionaires live there because of no income tax and Save our home protection and the everyday Joes let them get away with it. Builders pay off the politicos and build and build and build. 80 years of scams and its still going on.

Anonymous said...

Anon!

Go North young man!

I am sure they do it better!

Anonymous said...

We are saved! Pres.Bush has spoken and help in on the way!!

Anonymous said...

brazil,

By all means, jump in and buy now!
OOP's I forgot, you're a SELLER, not a buyer. HAHAHAHA
Good luck wit dat maan! LOL

Anonymous said...

BRAZIL,

On a more serious note, a week does not go by that I don't see MORE and MORE price REDUCTIONS on waterfront property in Lighthouse Point and Deerfield.
Why would I try to catch a falling knife?

Anonymous said...

140!
I am not selling anything, you got it all wrong. And i would and i am looking for a duplex right now. But not in the hurry. I am smarter than you, i buy when everybody else is selling.

Anonymous said...

braziliano,

You better put your pom poms away and start keeping up with current events.

By Reuters

Housing markets from Punta Gorda, Fla., to Stockton, Calif., will crash and suffer price drops of more than 30% before the housing crisis is over, a report from Moody's Economy.com said today.

On a national level, the housing market recession will continue through early 2009, said the report, co-authored by Mark Zandi, chief economist of Moody's Economy.com, and Celia Chen, director of housing economics.

The report paints a worsening picture of the hard-hit housing sector, which is in the midst of its worst downturn since World War II.

While activity will stabilize in 2009, it will be 2010 before a measurable improvement in sales, construction and pricing will emerge, the report said.
House prices are forecast to fall 13% from their peak through early 2009. After accounting for incentives home sellers are offering buyers, effective declines peak-to-trough will total well over 15%, the report said.

Punta Gorda, Fla., and Stockton, Calif,, are the hardest hit markets in the United States, with price declines from peak-to-trough forecast at 35.3% and 31.6%, respectively.

"This is the most severe housing recession since the post-World War II period," Zandi told Reuters.

These markets have been hard hit due to several reasons, namely the exiting of investors from the areas, a fair amount of subprime mortgage loans causing an increase in foreclosures and overbuilding by home builders, Zandi told Reuters.

Anonymous said...

Now that was funny Mr. 140. I think I might be more involved in RE than you are, believe me, I do follow everything!

Anonymous said...

Braziliano, name one state with the history of real estate fraud that FL has had? Name me one state ,right now, that has more mortgage fraud than the great FL?

Anonymous said...

Anon!
You are right on that one. But not the whole state, it is mostly in S.Florida.

Anonymous said...

Braziliano said...

Now that was funny Mr. 140. I think I might be more involved in RE than you are, believe me, I do follow everything!

Trust me braz, we KNOW you're all THAT. And a bag of chips. LOL

Anonymous said...

Mr 140

I am sorry that I do not share your total and dark pessimism regarding the RE market. I do not see and know the future like you do. I guess I am an optimistic guy!

Anonymous said...

Braziliano said...

Mr 140

I am sorry that I do not share your total and dark pessimism regarding the RE market. I do not see and know the future like you do. I guess I am an optimistic guy!

BRAZIL,

Is it the language barrier? Why do you struggle so with comprehension?
I am not dark at all, I am ELATED to watch RE prices dropping weekly, confident in the knowledge that they will soon be back to 2001 price levels.
Don't worry, be happy!
OOOppppsss!! I FORGOT, you are on the sell side of this wonderful phenomena. Maybe you SHOULD worry. LOL

Anonymous said...

when is this guy coming back?