Tuesday, August 28, 2007




Today's Local Real Estate News: "‘We're really in a crisis right now."

The Sun-Sentinel reports on dropping home prices and sales:

“Sales of existing homes in Broward County declined in July, just as they have for 36 of the past 37 months. That dismal trend isn't likely to change soon as lenders across South Florida make it tougher for consumers to qualify for mortgages.”

“Analysts don't expect the housing slump to end until the second half of 2008 or later, in part because the recent credit crunch is thinning an already small group of would-be buyers.”

“The county had 559 sales last month, down 22 percent from 721 in July 2006, the Florida Association of Realtors said Monday. The median price dropped 2 percent, to $373,700 from $380,400 last year.”

“The market for existing condominiums in Broward also took a hit in July. Year-over-year sales fell 19 percent, and the median price slid 10 percent, to $187,200 from $209,100 a year ago.”

“Existing sales and median prices could be even worse this fall in South Florida because those numbers will reflect the credit tightening that spread this month beyond risky borrowers to include people on solid financial footing.”

“‘There's more pain to go through,’ said John Burford, senior vice president and chief economist with The International Bank of Miami.”

The Sun-Sentinel’s report on Palm Beach county is even worse:

“Twenty months and counting.”

“Sales of existing homes in Palm Beach County slipped in July as they have since December 2005. That dismal trend isn't likely to change soon as lenders across South Florida make it tougher for consumers to qualify for mortgages.”

“Analysts don't expect the housing slump to end until the second half of 2008 or later, in part because the recent credit crunch is thinning an already small group of would-be buyers.”

“The county had 605 sales last month, down 15 percent from 714 in July 2006, the Florida Association of Realtors said Monday. The median price dropped 5 percent to $372,200 from $390,100 last year.”

“The market for existing condominiums looked particularly bleak in July, with year-over-year sales falling 14 percent and the median price plummeting 23 percent to $178,200 from $231,300 a year ago. It's the first time the median has dropped below $200,000 since September 2005.”

“Meanwhile, the percentage price decline in the county's existing condo sales was the second-worst showing among the state's 20 metropolitan markets, behind Lee County's 33 percent slide. The huge drop is an indication that less expensive condos were selling, and certain owners were desperate to unload them, analysts say.”

But, don’t worry, the Florida Association of Realtors® is reporting positive news in Miami-Dade (see my earlier post on how FAR uses the median price statistic as propaganda). The Miami Herald reports:

“For Miami-Dade condominiums, sales plunged 39 percent compared to a year ago and were flat compared to June.”

“Some experts attribute lackluster sales to sellers' unwillingness to lower prices in a meaningful way. While sellers still are balking at cutting prices to spur activity in hopes of a better deal, buyers continue to wait for better bargains.”

“The median price of a Miami-Dade single-family home was off only slightly in July compared to last year, declining 1 percent to $377,400, and was up 1 percent from June. Broward single-family home prices were down 2 percent to $373,700 compared to July 2006 and 2 percent from June.”

“Miami-Dade condo prices actually shot up significantly, rising 13 percent to $285,000 compared to the same month a year ago and 4 percent from June. Experts attribute the increase to relative strength in high-end condo sales, particularly to foreign buyers.”

“The total number of homes listed for sale grew to 78,959. That's a bit higher than June, when 78,066 houses and condos were for sale, and much higher than July 2006, when the number was 58,662.”

“But a new big cloud over the housing market is the troubled mortgage industry. Lenders who made too many risky loans are now tightening credit standards, making it harder to get a mortgage. That in turn will make it harder to reduce the glut of homes for sale.”

The New York Times reports on some South Beach condos facing foreclosure:

“The Savoy, which is known for its guitar-shaped pool, is going through court proceedings with a lender, the BankFirst Corporation. Court records show that in late June, the bank sued for $4.7 million, and last month, the court issued a lis pendens, a pre-foreclosure step stating that a suit is pending.’

“As the housing market began to slow, states like Florida have been particularly hard hit with home foreclosures, but until recently, the luxury end of the market seemed to be holding up. But the turn of events for the Savoy indicates that even luxury properties are getting a second look from banks that do the financing.”

“Seth Semilof, a former broker and publisher of the lifestyle magazine Haute Living, said that financial problems illustrated how difficult it had become to sell some projects even in desirable beachfront locations with brand-name architects and designers. In the past, other Miami projects that have run into trouble have been in less desirable sites.”

“‘You have a situation where you have one of the most beautiful locations in Miami right on the beach. You have an amazing architect. You have an amazing designer,’ Mr. Semilof said. ‘This is the first of many that’s going to go down.’”

“Jack McCabe, a real estate consultant in Deerfield Beach, Fla., said that the Savoy project was an example of the problems that luxury developers may face. Typically, he said a struggling developer will try to sell a project or form a venture with another developer to complete it.”

“‘This is just the start of the project foreclosures and this is going to accelerate over the next 24 months,’ he said. ‘We’re going to see commercial-owned foreclosures on new condominium projects, condo conversions, condo hotels.’”

The Street.com reports on another troubled development in Miami:

“The developers of Jade Ocean, a luxury high-rise condo near Miami Beach set to be completed in 2009, claim they've already sold 98% of the building's units -- a seemingly astounding feat given that many housing experts expect the Miami condo market to implode before the project is even finished.”

“Of course, the reality is that this ‘pre-construction sales’ number at Jade Ocean carries little meaning. It's a phrase that previously impressed people but carries little meaning in present-day Miami -- which is increasingly looking like the Netherlands in the aftermath of the Tulip Craze more than 300 years ago.”

“At the forefront of a looming crisis in the market is Corus Bancshares (CORS) , a Chicago-based bank that has been one of the largest construction lenders for Miami condos in recent years.”

“Skeptics say that buyers for Miami projects like Jade Ocean -- the largest of the Florida condo projects for which Corus has provided financing -- will have left the market in droves by the time the buildings are actually finished. Buyers will walk away from their 20%-down deposits because of rapidly falling prices and a huge inventory overhang that will only get worse in the market, several industry experts say.”

“Buyer cancellations in the Miami market will only get worse, says Jack McCabe, head of McCabe Research and Consulting. He expects walk-aways from new condo projects and deposits will reach 30% to 50% of sales through 2008 in the South Florida counties of Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach.”

“‘Corus is really in trouble,’ McCabe says. ‘The walk-away rate we are going to see is on more-expensive condos, primarily half a million [dollars] and above,’ where Corus has large exposure, he says.”

The Christian Science Monitor explains how tightened lending standards are affecting the market:

“Americans are quickly finding out that the turmoil in global credit markets is making it difficult – and in some cases impossible – to buy a home or refinance a mortgage.”

“Since the beginning of the month, lenders have tightened their standards. They are now very reluctant to make high-risk loans to individuals with spotty credit records. They're also requiring higher down payments, meaning that home buyers need to have much more money saved up. In addition, some Americans – including the self-employed, consultants who work from home, and those with unconventional sources of income – may be denied home loans.”

“The same is true in Florida, says Jack McCabe, CEO of McCabe Research & Consulting in Deerfield Beach, Fla. ‘Last year, over 50 percent of the mortgages made were volatile adjustable-rate mortgages,’ he says. ‘They were heavily used by speculators, and all income levels, and now with prices declining in Florida, we're seeing a large number of walkaway rates.’”

“For example, in Fort Myers, the foreclosure rate is up 400 percent over a year ago, Mr. McCabe says. ‘We're really in a crisis right now,’ he says.”

The Sun-Sentinel explains how the housing slump is affecting our state’s budget:

“Facing the worst budget crunch since the 2001 terrorist attacks devastated Florida's tourist economy, state legislators on Monday were told they might need to slash state spending by more than $2 billion over the next two years.”

“Florida's bleak housing market is the culprit, forcing a dramatic drop in state revenues collected through sales taxes and real estate transactions.”

“This week legislators have begun the task of looking to slash $1.1 billion out of the $71 billion state budget that took effect on July 1. Those cuts will be finalized during a three-week special session set to begin on Sept. 18.”

“It's anticipated the Legislature will have to trim up to another $900 million next spring when it must put together the next state budget.”

“Among the possible cuts in coming months are state spending on nursing home and hospital care for the poor. Also, university students could face higher tuition as soon as January and people who use state programs, such as parks, could be facing higher fees to make up some of the money.”

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

You know the market is F@cked when even the bogus median prices are coming down.

But, I thought Real Estate never goes down in value.

Anonymous said...

You People are a bunch of cheerleaders to a very serious and painful situation. I do not see what is your motivations, unless you are renting and would like to buy at cheaper prizes. Most of you remind me of Short Sellers of the stock market.

Braziliano

Anonymous said...

One more thing: How many of you own a home here in SF?

Anonymous said...

“Miami-Dade condo prices actually shot up significantly."

Okay. SFHB, you can take down the blog now. Everything's back to normal. Flippers, resume your flipping. The boom is officially back. Whew! Glad that's over.

I love the part about rich "foreign buyers" saving the day. Sorry, but these foreign buyers were simply foreign flippers. They were buying for the same reason as everyone else: to make a quick buck.

Anyone who is out there in the streets knows this "median price increasing" news is a bunch of baloney. Actually, anyone with an IQ over 75 would recognize this. Doesn't the fact that the phrase "prices up 13%" is preceded by "sales plunged 39 percent" tell you this is baloney?

Yeah--the old supply/demand curve doesn't apply to Miami. In Miami, when supply (inventory) increases and demand (buyers) decreases, prices go up instead of down! Yep--it's a totally new paradigm, people!

Anonymous said...

Flippers are gone from this market ( thank God) for a while anyway. Most of the people who are in trouble right now were flippers, or short-term investors, they created an artificial demand for properties!

Anonymous said...

Not cheerleaders.

Just rational people who saw the crisis coming two years back, when nobody wanted to listen. Now we are being rewarded for our patience and may soon be able to afford to buy a sensibly priced home.

The people being punished now BROUGHT THIS UPON THEMSELVES. The people I feel sorry for are folks who have been in a house for decades and are forced to sell for emergency reasons, and innocent business owners who will be crushed by a recession, and hard-working construction workers who will be short for jobs now.

Everybody else (brash Realtors, flippers, speculators, mortgage brokers, people who took on insane risk because "real estate always goes up", banks who should've known better), you are getting what you deserve. And you will keep getting what you deserve.

You want cheerleaders, turn your attention to the Miami Herald. They helped foster this mess down here.

Anonymous said...

Just an idea: if you do not want me to call you a cheerleader or a genius, start to use a nick name at least!

Anonymous said...

Braziliano,
Great the US economy is like yours.
How many times did the Brazilian government devalue the dollar in Brazil?

Thanks for all of your help.

Anonymous said...

I am a US citizen, not just on paper but in my heart also! Do not care about the Gov. of Brazil!

Anonymous said...

Braziliano,

I think you're mistaken in assuming that people who follow the real estate bubble are cheerleaders for a bottom.

Many of us are like me, a real estate investor, who is simply looking for alternative ways of following the market.

Unfortunately, the newspapers down here in South Florida simply aren't reporting the truth. Realtor groups are not reporting the truth. So, I have to rely on blogs like this one and thehousingbubbleblog.com to see what's really happening.

Personally, I am losing big time on my last three properties that I'm holding. I will probably resort to a fire sale to get rid of them.

The good news is I made a bundle during the boom and banked plenty of money to easily cover the losses I expect on these last three properties.

I also plan on flipping again, but will wait out the market until I think a bottom hits again. But, I'm certainly not a cheerleader for a bottom (at least not until I get rid of these last three properties).

Besides, what are you doing here? It's seems like you're reading too.

Anonymous said...

Braziliano:

I personally feel bad for some of the people who are being hurt by the real estate crash.

However, many other people were clearly asking for it and are getting their justice.

To answer your question, I did own a townhouse. I sold it in early 2006 simply because I felt that I could take the money I received from the sale and put it into an investment with a guaranteed return and rent an equivalent place while the storm blew over.

I also felt that I would be able to either buy a similar place back for less money when the market bottomed out, or buy a nicer place for the same amount of money. I'm very happy with my decision. I can already buy a single family home for the same price I sold my townhouse. Also--I'm very happy renting. I'm living in a nicer place than before and I don't worry about insurance premiums, HOAs, and hurricanes anymore.

Mostly, though, I'm just happy to see some rationality return to the markets. I really didn't like watching people making tons of money through the great Ponzi scheme that was the recent real estate boom.

I will buy real estate again when it makes sense. My definition of "makes sense": when owning a property costs less, all things considered, than renting it.

As late as 2001, it was actually cheaper to own a property than to rent it. Even now with declining prices, it's still roughly 2x more expensive to buy than to rent. When fundamentals are that out of whack, it's a bad time to buy.

The dot-com stock boom collapsed because the fundamentals didn't make sense (company with 0 or negative earnings can't survive forever). Real estate is falling in price for the same reason. Until the fundamentals make sense again, you won't see the market bottom out.

Anonymous said...

I think this is just a correction of the market.

Those who bought a lot of properties and did a lot of money as this investor will have a few losses and that's it;

The amateurs who took too many risks are going to be punished and loose their investments.

It was actually the same thing for the dot.com boom. The wise professionals did a lot of money. The amateurs loose the little money they played with. Same rules, other game. There is no such thing as easy money.

FD ( Condo Hotel Miami Beach )

Anonymous said...

pp,

Thanks for letting us know this is just a correction and not a crash.

I wasn't sure if I should believe you, but then I clicked on your link and knew you were a credible source.

pfff

Anonymous said...

"I think this is just a correction of the market"

I think most people would agree that a "crash" IS a correction. A large correction.

We could argue semantics, but prices declining 30% or more would qualify as a "crash".

You can call it a correction if you wish. It doesn't really matter.

Anonymous said...

Up to this point it's been a correction. However, we're just finishing the first inning of a nine inning game.

I challenge "pp" or anyone else calling this a correction to come back here in 18 months and call it a correction then.